Expense of possible AV Ranchos acquisition difficult to gauge (March 14, 2015)
APPLE VALLEY — When town officials recently embarked on a possible purchase or takeover of the Apple Valley Ranchos Water Co., they knew the move involved risk and undetermined costs.
Algonquin Power Co.’s Liberty Utilities has agreed to purchase Western Water Holdings LLC — a Carlyle Group company — for $325 million, including $80 million in debt. Western Water Holdings LLC owns Apple Valley Ranchos and other water companies under Park Water Co.
If the merger and acquisition is finalized, the town will not know beforehand how the water company purchase will affect ratepayers, because the potential buyers refuse to produce documents to the town, Town Manager Frank Robinson said.
The town is interested in maintaining and providing quality and reliable services to our residents and ratepayers.
The Town of Apple Valley has expressed a strong interest in purchasing Apple Valley Ranchos Water Co. in order to gain local control that will help moderate customer rates, officials say. Customers have complained to the town about the rise in rates, and the town’s cost of operating parks and the Apple Valley Golf Course has been impacted.
Robinson said the acquiring utilities have no experience operating a water system in California and do not have vested interests to the residents or ratepayers. Liberty Utilities does operate water systems in Arizona, however.
We are interested in knowing what measures the (California Public Utilities) Commission will take to ensure ratepayers are not paying for the overpriced offer submitted by Algonquin and Liberty, he wrote.
The Commission must ensure that the regulatory commitments identified in the merger application, including the commitment that the cost of the transaction will not be passed on to ratepayers, are enforceable and that the utility has the affirmative obligation to show compliance.
Meanwhile, the costs of reliably providing clean and safe water is climbing everywhere, especially because of the expense of replacing aging delivery systems and components. It is a situation prevailing nationwide, as noted by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.
In Claremont, where that city is trying to acquire the Golden State Water Co. system serving its nearly 36,000 residents, Golden State said a couple of years ago the value of land and assets the company owns there exceeded $200 million. In court documents, Golden State said even at an acquisition cost of $120 million, the city would not break even until 17 years later.
In Apple Valley and adjacent unincorporated areas to the east, nearly 20,000 connections are served by the Apple Valley Ranchos Water Co. with 450 miles of pipeline, which Park Water Co. CEO Chris Shilling said would be valued at $1 million a mile. The length of
pipeline also includes storage tanks, pumps, service trucks, offices, and employees.
If the town proceeds with an unnecessary takeover of Ranchos, we do know it will be a lengthy and costly legal process, AVR General Manager Tony Penna said.
No one knows the full cost of taking over Ranchos, as the fair value for all of the assets of this system plus possible damages will be determined ultimately in a jury trial.
History, though, has proven it costs far more than what politicians and their paid consultants initially promise. The town has other priorities that are more important to the future of Apple Valley.
The Town of Apple Valley has taken a long look at the matter.
The town has previously hired experienced financial advisers to assist in reviewing the funding options available to the town should it purchase Apple Valley Ranchos Water Co., Robinson said.
We have also retained a utility valuation expert to assist in determining a value.
The company was purchased less than four years ago as part of the sale of Park Water Co. to Carlyle Infrastructure Partners, and that purchase price roughly provides some indication of the value of Park Water. The city of Missoula, Montana is presently condemning (another) part of Park Water Co., Mountain Water Co., and those valuations provide additional information as to the fair market value of that portion of Park Water Co. If Mountain Water Co. is condemned, the operational and financial components of what remains of Park Water Co. will need to be assessed.
With uncertainties abounding, the town is taking the exploration process one step at a time.
At this point all we have is the Feasibility Study that shows we (can) afford to purchase Ranchos Water under certain parameters, Apple Valley Town Councilman Scott Nassif said in an email.
We have commissioned an appraisal of Ranchos from both an infrastructure and business value point of view.
Once we we have the appraisal we can then look at all the town’s options. We hope to have the appraisal ready to present at a council meeting within the next 30 to 45 days.
In the weeks to come the town expects to hold one or more town hall meetings to discuss the possible purchase of Apple Valley Ranchos Water Co. At that time, it is expected that additional information regarding the estimated fair market value of Apple Valley Ranchos Water Co., as well as costs and expenses associated with the acquisition of Park Water Co. and the benefits of public ownership of the local water system, will be discussed in more detail.
If the town were to move on the appraisal and call for an election to register voter sentiment on the issue, the town clerk estimates the cost for a special election could be about $186,000 — a figure based on how much the off-year November 2013 Wal-Mart ballot Measure D cost to conduct.
If a ballot question is part of a General Election, we estimate it would be slightly less than half that, town spokeswoman Kathie Martin said.
Source: Gary Brodeur, Daily Press
Files related to Claremont
- 20150308 Acquiring AVRWC is right move for Apple Valley
- 20150314 Expense of possible AVRWC acquisition difficult to gauge
- 20150514 Claremont Water System — Supplement to 2012 Appraisal Report
- 20150905 Letter: Lawyers, water, and money (O’Neil)
- 20150918 TOAV fires back at Coupal
- 20150923 Editorial: Water, takeovers, and the people
- 20151015 Cities and private equity firms fight over ownership of water systems
- 20160712 Public records request (Manning)
- 20160721 Conflict of interest (Manning)
- 20160904 Letter: Peter Allen supporting Measure V (Nassif)
- 20161012 Claremont Set To Raise Rates For Utilities
- 20161018 Will Apple Valley become California’s Flint, MI?
- 20161110 Statement of tentative decision (Claremont v. Golden State Water)
- 20161110 Judge issues tentative decision against city in water system acquisition trial (Claremont v. Golden State Water)
- 20161114 Measures V and W
- 20161115 Polls and votes
- 20161116 Another false narrative
- 20161116 Liberty sees Claremont’s eminent-domain loss as sign of things to come in Apple Valley
- 20161121 Voters show they want a say in water takeover issue (Hanson)
- 20161215 Another costly day for Apple Valley
- 20161218 Time to pay attention: An open letter to Larry Cusack
- 20170111 Claremont city manager getting a $21,000 bonus
- 20170114 Price tag for Claremont’s failed attempt to take over water system keeps rising
- 20170115 Our View: Time for foes to sit down and talk
- Time for the Town Council to listen for a change
- Response to Thomas Lecoq (Carloni)
- Time for a second opinion? (Carloni)
- 20170209 Avoiding the Claremont disaster (video)
- 20170213 Valley Voices: Apple Valley would be wise to work with Liberty Utilities (Wright)
- 20170216 James Belna on the Claremont eminent domain disaster (video)
- 20170220 Claremont resident talks [about] avoiding ‘disaster’ in Apple Valley
- 20170220 Conflict of interest
- 20170220 Letter: Response to Thomas Rice (Belna)
- 20170226 Letter: James Belna’s visit (Hanson)
- 20170226 Letter: Rice rebuttal (Trozpek)
- Claremont public records request
- Truth not tricks (Carloni)
- Comments to the Town Council opposing the ballot measure
- 20170314 Town Council meeting (McCarthy)
- 20170322 Skewing the facts (Hanson)
- 20170323 Letter: Sit down and settle (Henard)
- 20170406 Guest commentary: Government takeovers of water systems don’t deliver results — study
- Who pays?
- Responding to claims made on Facebook
- 20170508 Liberty Utilities radio ad — Claremont (audio)
- Not paying attention
- 20171010 Claremont reaches $4.8 million settlement agreement with Golden State Water
- 20171017 Claremont settlement reignites Apple Valley water war
- 20171026 Claremont cuts ties with its city attorney, law firm