Conflict of interest (February 20, 2017)
There is one aspect of James Belna’s excellent presentation about the parallels between Claremont and Apple Valley regarding eminent domain water system takeover not mentioned in your coverage of the event, nor addressed by Town Manager Frank Robinson or by Town Attorney Thomas Rice: The built-in conflict of interest in each of these cases (Claremont resident talks [about] avoiding ‘disaster’ in Apple Valley,
Daily Press, February 20, 2017).
As Belna pointed out, for both Claremont and Apple Valley, the city attorney is from the law firm of Best Best & Krieger (BB&K). The takeover policy advisors are from BB&K. The litigators are also from BB&K. Thus, the lawyers who are paid to provide advice to town leaders are also the ones those advisors recommend to litigate the case. Should there be a need to appeal an adverse decision, as there was in Claremont, BB&K makes even more money. That means that all aspects of both the proposed and actual litigation — including the reasonableness of the fees and expenses for doing this work — are overseen by attorneys employed by the firm doing the billing.
The only persons who do not have a seat at the table
are the taxpayers and ratepayers who must ultimately provide the money to pay these millions of dollars in legal fees and billings. Regardless of the outcome, taxpayers and ratepayers lose.
So when Town Attorney Rice assures us that Belna’s closely-reasoned position is absolute nonsense,
and Town Manager Robinson assures us that the two seemingly identical situations are somehow dissimilar, they are each supporting the position of the only group that stands to gain from these continuing catastrophes: The attorneys.
— Greg Raven is Co-Chair of Apple Valley Citizens for Government Accountability, and is concerned about quality of life issues.
Published: Daily Press, February 28, 2017
Files related to Claremont
- 20150308 Acquiring AVRWC is right move for Apple Valley
- 20150314 Expense of possible AVRWC acquisition difficult to gauge
- 20150514 Claremont Water System — Supplement to 2012 Appraisal Report
- 20150905 Letter: Lawyers, water, and money (O’Neil)
- 20150918 TOAV fires back at Coupal
- 20150923 Editorial: Water, takeovers, and the people
- 20151015 Cities and private equity firms fight over ownership of water systems
- 20160712 Public records request (Manning)
- 20160721 Conflict of interest (Manning)
- 20160904 Letter: Peter Allen supporting Measure V (Nassif)
- 20161012 Claremont Set To Raise Rates For Utilities
- 20161018 Will Apple Valley become California’s Flint, MI?
- 20161110 Statement of tentative decision (Claremont v. Golden State Water)
- 20161110 Judge issues tentative decision against city in water system acquisition trial (Claremont v. Golden State Water)
- 20161114 Measures V and W
- 20161115 Polls and votes
- 20161116 Another false narrative
- 20161116 Liberty sees Claremont’s eminent-domain loss as sign of things to come in Apple Valley
- 20161121 Voters show they want a say in water takeover issue (Hanson)
- 20161215 Another costly day for Apple Valley
- 20161218 Time to pay attention: An open letter to Larry Cusack
- 20170111 Claremont city manager getting a $21,000 bonus
- 20170114 Price tag for Claremont’s failed attempt to take over water system keeps rising
- 20170115 Our View: Time for foes to sit down and talk
- Time for the Town Council to listen for a change
- Response to Thomas Lecoq (Carloni)
- Time for a second opinion? (Carloni)
- 20170209 Avoiding the Claremont disaster (video)
- 20170213 Valley Voices: Apple Valley would be wise to work with Liberty Utilities (Wright)
- 20170216 James Belna on the Claremont eminent domain disaster (video)
- 20170220 Claremont resident talks [about] avoiding ‘disaster’ in Apple Valley
- 20170220 Conflict of interest
- 20170220 Letter: Response to Thomas Rice (Belna)
- 20170226 Letter: James Belna’s visit (Hanson)
- 20170226 Letter: Rice rebuttal (Trozpek)
- Claremont public records request
- Truth not tricks (Carloni)
- Comments to the Town Council opposing the ballot measure
- 20170314 Town Council meeting (McCarthy)
- 20170322 Skewing the facts (Hanson)
- 20170323 Letter: Sit down and settle (Henard)
- 20170406 Guest commentary: Government takeovers of water systems don’t deliver results — study
- Who pays?
- Responding to claims made on Facebook
- 20170508 Liberty Utilities radio ad — Claremont (audio)
- Not paying attention
- 20171010 Claremont reaches $4.8 million settlement agreement with Golden State Water
- 20171017 Claremont settlement reignites Apple Valley water war
- 20171026 Claremont cuts ties with its city attorney, law firm