Audit details shortfalls in financial procedures (September 9, 1999)
By Ron Fonger, JOURNAL STAFF WRITER
Auditors are suggesting there are not enough workers in the city’s Finance Department to keep financial records properly maintained.
In a five-page report to Mayor Woodrow Stanley and the City Council, auditors Dupuis & Ryden said it found significant deficiencies in the city’s internal controls over financial reporting.
Among the firm’s findings:
- The city apparently violated state law by spending beyond the budget adopted by the City Council in some areas.
- A lack of employees in the city finance and budget departments has resulted in transactions not being recorded on the city’s general ledger in a timely way, making it impossible to compare the city budget to its actual spending on a monthly or quarterly basis.
- Procedures have not provided for an interim review of the general ledger account balances, resulting in errors not being detected until the annual audit.
- During 1998, bank reconciliations for some accounts were not performed on a timely basis — some not prepared until seven months after the close of the year, including the main pooled cash checking and investment account, which had more than $97 million in cash and investments.
Brian Ross of Dupuis & Ryden said some of the conditions have continued for years, but have risen to the level of
reportable conditions, which mean there are significant internal control deficiencies.
Council members, who have watched a series of financial calamities unfold inside city hall in 1999, said they hope the audit report, covering the fiscal year that ended June 30, 1998, signals an end to the fiscal problems.
Since I have been here, all I’ve heard is what a mess the city’s finances are, said 3rd Ward Councilman Johnnie Coleman.
I don’t want to see this another year.
Top Stanley officials said the report to the City Council on Wednesday produced little new information and said most issues identified in the audit letter have been or are being addressed.
I am glad to see it … I want to say, ‘This is what’s happened. What are we going to do about that? How do I keep that from happening again?’ said Finance Director Matthew Grady.
Council members have been supportive of Grady since Stanley appointed the former budget director to replace Marc Puckett, who resigned as the mayor’s finance director after revealing the city’s failure to properly transfer $19 million to its pension fund over two years.
That mistake alone cost Flint taxpayers nearly $1 million as lost interest was paid back to retirees with money that could have been used for street sweeping, police protection or other services.
Flint officials also acknowledged this year they had incorrectly distributed some $6 million in tax dollars collected for city schools, Bishop Airport and other Genesee County entities — a problem that has yet to be fully resolved.
And the city and state continue to discuss Flint’s failure to pay industrial and commercial facility taxes since 1996.
The financial difficulties led Stanley to roll out a four-point fiscal integrity plan designed to restore confidence in Flint’s ability to manage money.
One piece of that plan was Grady’s appointment. The new finance director said he is taking a different approach to dealing with problems he inherited, including involving more of his staff in discussions of problems and increasing the responsibility of division heads.
In previous years, he said, Puckett often didn’t share information as freely. City Administrator David H. Ready said some key accounting positions remain vacant in the city despite efforts to fill them. Staffing shortages are getting more manageable, he said, as the city institutes new accounting software.
Ron Fonger covers government in Flint and Genesee County, and Bishop Airport. He can be reached at (810) 766-6317.
Copyright Flint Journal / MLive Media Group (mlive.com). Used with permission.
Files dealing with Marc Puckett
- 19920114 Minutes of a special meeting of the city council for the City of East Detroit, Macomb County, Michigan
- 19920225 Minutes of a special meeting of the city council for the City of East Detroit, Macomb County, Michigan
- 19920303 Minutes of a special meeting of the city council for the City of East Detroit, Macomb County, Michigan
- 19920305 Minutes of a special meeting of the city council for the City of East Detroit, Macomb County, Michigan
- 19920319 Minutes of a special meeting of the city council for the City of East Detroit, Macomb County, Michigan
- 19920623 Minutes of a special meeting of the city council for the City of East Detroit, Macomb County, Michigan
- 19960111 Retirement firm accuses official of favoritism
- 19960403 Folks soaked by water bills may get relief
- 19960920 Marc Puckett’s red light ticket
- 19990130 $9-million pension fund transfer raises questions
- 19990202 Retirement panel urges ‘immediate’ audit of plan
- 19990203 Retirement board splits over need for independent manager
- 19990203 Finance director resigns under fire of pension flap
- 19990210 Former finance director lashes back at critics, hints suit
- 19990224 Flint to boost pension fund
- 19990319 Flint sent tax funds to wrong units
- 19990326 Ex-finance director cashes in on $6,000 in unused vacation time
- 19990330 Flint could owe state millions some industrial facilities taxes have not been paid since 1996
- 19990408 Stanley acts on money woes, appoints new finance chief
- 19990411 Stanley must share blame as part of his plan to fix city’s financial woes
- 19990909 Audit details shortfalls in financial procedures
- 20100219 Personal injury complaint against Marc Puckett
- 20100408 Answer of defendant, Marc R. Puckett, to plaintiffs’ complaint
- 20101227 New finance director to step down
- 20101228 Marc Puckett out — Again
- 20101230 Leadership turmoil
- 20110104 The world according to John Moorlach
- 20110110 City faces $231,000 deficit
- 20110113 Interim finance director named
- 20110210 Marc Puckett’s speeding ticket
- 201102405 Marc Puckett’s ticket for stopping on a red signal
- 20110817 Marc Puckett’s ticket for no license plate
- 20120309 Marc Puckett’s Orange County accident case information
- 20120425 Marc Puckett’s speeding ticket
- 20120703 Marc Puckett’s speeding ticket
- 20140724 Marc Puckett’s speeding ticket
- 20141124 Marc Puckett’s ticket for coasting out of gear
- 20141205 Marc Puckett’s ticket for speeding
- 20150529 Marc Puckett’s ticket for improper use of preferred lane
- Comments for tonight’s council meeting
- The innumerate Mr. Puckett
- Shill crazy after all these years
- Earth to Puckett!
- About those awards
- One PRR story: American Express (CC)
- 20160913 Documents link top Apple Valley official to #FlintWaterCrisis
- 20160913 Investigation: Flint / Apple Valley Connection
- 20160915 Economic Speech (Trump)
- 20161018 Will Apple Valley become California’s Flint, MI?
- 20170319 Trump EPA grants Michigan $100 million to fix Flint water system
- 20170320 Sinkhole: Effort to replace pipes to Flint homes off to slow start
- 20170806 Vehicle belonging to AV town manager involved in hit-and-run
- He’s gonna need a good lawyer
- 20170809 Apple Valley official believes Liberty could have followed him before crash
- Public trust destroyed (Carloni)
- 20170907 Hit-and-run investigation involving Marc Puckett’s Cadillac sent to DA
- 20171010 Marc Puckett’s speeding ticket
- A question of character
- 20171206 Apple Valley Finance Director Marc Puckett charged with felony hit-and-run
- 20171206 A long wait for crash victim
- 20171117 A history of infractions
- 20171207 Apple Valley Finance Director Marc Puckett on personal leave after felony hit-and-run charge filed
- 20171214 Apple Valley Finance Director Marc Puckett pleads not guilty to felony hit-and-run charge
- 20171214 I-15 crash victim seeks $2M in damages from Apple Valley
- 20171219 Editorial: Passing the Puck (Valles)
- 20171228 Town Hall position not a factor in Puckett’s custody status, attorney says
- 20180105 Puckett forced out as Apple Valley’s Assistant Manager & Finance Director
- 20180109 Tin Cup Men (Valles)
- 20180116 Puckett’s dismissal just what the town needed (Valles)
- 20180307 Puckett deposition set for mid-April in town’s eminent domain case
- 20180425 Pre-plea report ordered in Puckett’s felony case