What Are We Doing?
Opposing the hostile takeover of Liberty Apple Valley
In the past week, there have been two letters to the editor suggesting Liberty Utilities is somehow delaying the eminent domain process. Obviously, the authors of these false impressions don’t understand the process. As an attorney, my opposition to eminent domain is based on research, professional reports, and the almost daily stories of water mains breaking in Los Angeles and other cities.
The Town of Apple Valley has never successfully run a water agency, and to say it can do it better than Liberty is a fiction. The town will cost the ratepayers millions in rate increases or it will let infrastructure rot. The town’s claimed “savings” are a fiction and defy common sense. Mr. Puckett’s reports are neither believable nor based on fact. They resemble his fairy tale about something running in front of him on the freeway.
If town residents think that $150 million is enough to purchase the AV water system, they are sorely mistaken. The hard system the town values at $84 million, and the water itself is $65.4 million, thereby exhausting the bond BEFORE costs of financing, attorney fees for the town and Liberty, prepaid interest, etc.
People buy into politician’s stories when they think it will help their wallets. The town is only interested in enlarging its coffers, per goal eight of the Vision 2020 plan. I can only tell the residents to investigate the facts. I can advocate against the takeover. But ultimately a judge will decide the right to take and a jury will decide the value. I conclude that a judge will likely reject the right to take because, like in Claremont, Liberty provides great customer service and maintains the system to a high standard, so the notion of a takeover is, also, nothing more than political fantasy.
Diana J. Carloni, Apple Valley
Source: Daily Press